On Cloud vs Brooks — Which Is Better for Flat Feet?
Flat feet often require strong arch support, structured stability, and proper heel containment to prevent inward rolling. On Cloud models emphasize reinforced sidewalls and structured midfoot stability, while many Brooks models focus on softer neutral cushioning with select stability options.
For flat feet and moderate to strong overpronation, On models like the Cloudflyer 5 and Cloudrunner 3 typically provide stronger structural support. Brooks stability models offer guidance, but On often feels firmer and more corrective.
If arch collapse is significant, On generally has the edge.
Quick Brand Comparison Table
| Feature | On | Brooks | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arch Support | 9.9/10 | 9.6/10 | On |
| Stability | 9.9/10 | 9.6/10 | On |
| Cushioning | 9.8/10 | 9.8/10 | Tie |
| Heel Containment | 9.9/10 | 9.6/10 | On |
| Best For | Structured flat foot support | Softer guidance feel | On for correction |
Best On Models for Flat Feet
Cloudflyer 5 — Maximum Motion Control
Check Price on Amazon (Cloudflyer 5)
Provides firm structural support ideal for moderate to severe arch collapse.
Cloudrunner 3 — Balanced Stability
Check Price on Amazon (Cloudrunner 3)
Offers strong midfoot support with slightly softer cushioning.
Cloudstratus 3 — Cushion + Structure
Check Price on Amazon (Cloudstratus 3)
Good for users who want support without excessive firmness.
Stability and Arch Support
Flat feet can lead to:
- Overpronation
- Knee strain
- Lower back discomfort
- Heel pain
On stability-focused models help maintain neutral alignment.
Check Price on Amazon (Cloudflyer 5)
Cushioning vs Structural Correction
If flat feet cause alignment issues → prioritize structural stability.
If discomfort is impact-driven → cushioning may help.
Strong midfoot structure usually provides more reliable long-term support.
Who Should Choose Brooks?
Brooks may work well for flat feet if:
- Overpronation is mild
- You prefer softer cushioning
- You want lighter guidance
Who Should Choose On?
On is ideal for flat feet if:
- Arch collapse is moderate to severe
- You stand all day
- You experience knee or back strain
- You want firmer corrective support
FAQs
Is On better than Brooks for flat feet?
For stronger arch support and motion control, On often performs better.
Are Brooks shoes supportive?
Yes — but they may feel softer and less corrective.
Which is better for severe flat feet?
On stability models like the Cloudflyer 5 are typically stronger.
Are both good for standing all day?
Yes — but support needs determine the better choice.
Final Verdict
When comparing On Cloud vs Brooks for flat feet, both brands offer supportive options. However, On models like the Cloudflyer 5 and Cloudrunner 3 provide stronger structural control and arch stability, making them better suited for moderate to severe flat foot conditions.
For softer guidance, Brooks may appeal. For firm corrective support, On stands out.
Check Price on Amazon (Cloudflyer 5)
